back to the home page

"The everyday consumer's guide to 
DVD & home theater"

Try NetFlix online DVD rentals for free
Try NetFlix online DVD rentals for free
 

back to the home pagenew to DVD or home theater?buying a DVD player?DVD movie releases and reviewsnews, FAQs, glossary and linkssite info

Panic Room

Superbit


Panic Room (Superbit)Movie B+ | Video  A | Audio A+ | Extras D

Jodie Foster, Forest Whitaker, Dwight Yoakam, Jared Leto, 
and Kristen Stewart
director David Fincher | Columbia Pictures
2002 | Suspense - Thriller | R | 112 minutes
Region 1 | DVD-9 | anamorphic widescreen 2.35:1 aspect ratio 
DTS 5.1 | Dolby Digital 5.1

Summary: Jodie Foster is Meg Altman, a single mother and student with a young teenage daughter Sarah who is diabetic.  They're moving into a new house in Manhattan to be closer to their schools, thanks to the generous financial support from her estranged husband.  The house that they selected is quite large and was formerly owned by a wealthy man.  It features a seemingly odd panic room, a solid steel and concrete reinforced hiding room for taking refuge from unexpected intruders and other threats, complete with its own telephone line, an array of closed-circuit security cameras and monitors, independent air conditioning and ventilation systems, an emergency supply of food, water, and other provisions and necessities.

     During the first night of occupancy by the mother and daughter Altmans, three mysterious men break into their new home.  Upon realizing this, Meg quickly pulls her daughter into the safety of the panic room and locks themselves in.  Will they be able to summon for help?  Will Meg be able to overcome her claustrophobia long enough to keep her diabetic daughter calm and properly nourished to maintain her blood sugar level?  Panic Room will likely keep you on the edge of your seat.  It's amazing that the majority of this movie is set within the confines of this house and its panic room.  It's a chilling story concept.

     As Columbia TriStar's first Superbit release of a recent theatrical film, Panic Room under whelms me with its mediocre level of visual details.  Superbit DVDs typically exemplifies the best possible picture quality that DVD has to offer, offering a more detailed picture than typical DVD transfers.  The film was shot with cinematic finesse and interesting vertical pans across the different floors of the house and fly-through shots that take the viewers through wall and furniture, but the film intentionally exhibits a considerable amount of grain.  With most other Superbit releases, the bit rate is usually maintained at 5-7 Mbits/sec (Mbps) consistently and rarely drops below 5 Mbps.  However, the bit rate for Panic Room frequently drops below 5 Mbps to as low as 4 Mbps.  So the combination of a grainy film stock and lower than typical Superbit bit rates result in a less than stellar picture quality.  The audio quality was more typical Superbit quality, fortunately.  The DTS soundtrack sounded full and detailed.

    Other than the detailed DTS soundtrack, this Panic Room Superbit DVD release seems rather substandard in comparison of other previous Superbit releases in terms of picture detail.  If you pick up this DVD for the movie, don't read too much from the picture quality.  Typical Superbit releases do offer better picture quality than this.

Special Features: As a regular Superbit DVD, there isn't much bonus materials here, by design: theatrical trailer and filmographies

DVD released on 9/17/2002 | Reviewed 10/06/2002

List $27.96 | online $20.49 | order from Amazon.com, Buy.com

Rent this DVD from NetFlix - Try the " Unlimited" DVD rental program absolutely free!

 

Additional Notes: Unless we specify otherwise, the video and audio quality are very good when their grades are "A-" or better.  Only the highest number of channels of surround sound format is listed (e.g., Dolby Digital 5.1).  If there are both Dolby Digital 5.1 and DTS 5.1 soundtracks, then both are listed.  All DVD-Video discs are backwards compatible with stereo-only playback systems.

Let us know what you think about this DVD review, write to us at Editor@TimeForDVD.com.

Keep up with new and upcoming DVD releases, and our new DVD reviews, sign up for our free e-Newsletter.

Associated equipment used in evaluation: Sony DVP-S7700 reference DVD player, Sony KP-61V45 61" rear projection TV (4:3 screen aspect ratio), Sony ES STR-V444ES A/V receiver, four B&W CDM 9NTs as left/right main speakers and left/right surrounds, B&W CDM CNT center channel speaker, Monster Cable M-series S-Video cable MSV-500, Monster Cable Interlink LightSpeed 100 (Toslink) optical cable, Monster Cable Interlink 400 MKII interconnects, Monster Cable Original speaker cables in bi-wire configuration with Monster Cable twist-on gold-plated banana plug connectors, Lovan Sovereign T HiFi audio rack, and Sony MDR-V600 studio monitor headphones.  Our home theater equipment was calibrated with the Video Essentials DVD.

Be sure to check out our Top 10 DVDs of the year 2001 and our list of this year's Oscar winners on DVD.

 

 

Special Offers:

 

NetFlix

 »

Try the "Unlimited" DVD rental service absolutely free
for two weeks.  More info
 

OneCall.com

 »

10% off all DVD players & recorders $200 or more,
10% off & free shipping on all 16:9 rear projection TVs,
10% off all receivers $300 or more,
and a coupon for up to $375 in savings.
Details here
 

hifi.com

 »

Free shipping for a limited time.  Details here
 

AllSat.com

 »

Get a free 50-channel DISH Network satellite TV system
with free installation, for $24.99 per month, and 
get 3 months free
of the Dish Network Value Pack 
($149 value).  Details here
 

Amazon.com

 »

Get a hot new cell phone at a competitive on-line price, with the guarantee of a 30-day return policy.  Details here
 

Support this site

 »

 

Click through our links and buy from our online affiliates.
 

Site updated 5.30.2007


United We Stand  United We Stand

 


 

Search this site
 

read our PDA version / mobile edition

PDA Version /
Mobile Edition

 


Latest DVD Reviews

 

> The Good Sheperd

> Volver

> Charlotte's Web

> Superman Returns

more >>   

 


DVD Movies On Sale

 

> Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers $17.97 (40% off) & free shipping!

more >>   

 




Copyright © 2000-2007 TimeForDVD.com - All rights reserved

Read our terms of use and privacy policy before using this site

This site is a Region 1 resource for DVD software & hardware info

Contact us: Editor@TimeForDVD.com 

Site optimized for 800x600 displays

and Internet Explorer 5 or better

Print using 85% scale factor